Sole Trader vs Limited Company: Which Structure Saves You More in 2025/26?
The right choice could save you thousands annually. Understand the real tax differences, Making Tax Digital requirements from April 2026, and when to make the switch.
If you're running a business in London or planning to start one, choosing between operating as a sole trader or forming a limited company is one of your most important financial decisions. The structure you choose affects how much tax you pay, your admin burden, your legal liability, and your professional credibility. From April 2026, new Making Tax Digital requirements for self-employed individuals earning £50,000+ add another crucial factor to this decision.
Quick Comparison: Sole Trader vs Limited Company
| Factor | Sole Trader | Limited Company |
|---|---|---|
| Tax Treatment | Income Tax (20%-45%) + National Insurance (6%-9%). All profit is taxable. | Corporation Tax (19%-25%) on company profit. Dividends taxed at 8.75%-39.35%. More tax-efficient at higher profits. |
| Legal Liability | Unlimited personal liability. Your personal assets are at risk if business fails. | Limited liability. Your personal assets are protected (except in cases of fraud or personal guarantees). |
| Admin Requirements | Simple Self Assessment once yearly. From April 2026: quarterly filings if turnover £50K+. | Annual accounts, Corporation Tax return, director Self Assessment, Companies House filing, payroll compliance. |
| Setup Cost | Free to start. Just register with HMRC. | £12-£100 incorporation fee. May need accountant help. |
| Ongoing Costs | Under £50K turnover: £300 one-off tax return. Over £50K turnover (from April 2026): £600/year with quarterly MTD filings. | Typically £150-£250/month (£1,800-£3,000/year) for full accounting service including payroll and compliance. |
| Professional Credibility | Some clients perceive sole traders as less established. Can be harder to win larger contracts. | Limited company status signals professionalism and permanence. Often preferred by corporate clients. |
| Privacy | Your finances stay private. No public record of income. | Annual accounts are public record on Companies House. Anyone can see your turnover and profit. |
| Pension Contributions | Can make personal pension contributions and claim tax relief. | Company can make employer pension contributions which are fully tax-deductible business expenses. More tax-efficient. |
| Taking Money Out | All profit is yours automatically. No restrictions on withdrawing money. | Must pay yourself via salary and dividends. Requires proper bookkeeping and cannot just withdraw cash freely. |
| Ideal For | New businesses, side hustles, profits under £30K, prefer simplicity, testing business ideas. | Established businesses, profits £30K-£50K+, need liability protection, want tax efficiency, planning to grow. |
Critical Change: Making Tax Digital from April 2026
If you're a sole trader or self-employed individual with annual turnover of £50,000 or more, HMRC is introducing major new requirements from April 2026 that will significantly impact your accounting obligations and costs.
What is Making Tax Digital (MTD) for Income Tax?
From 6 April 2026, if your self-employed or property income exceeds £50,000 per year, you must:
✓ Keep digital records of all income and expenses using MTD-compatible software
✓ Submit quarterly updates to HMRC (every three months) showing your income and expenses
✓ Submit a final declaration at the end of the tax year
✓ Use bridging software to connect your records to HMRC systems
How This Affects Your Accounting Costs:
Before April 2026 (current rules): Sole traders with any level of turnover typically pay £300 one-off for annual Self Assessment tax return preparation and submission.
After April 2026 (£50K+ turnover): Because chartered accountants must prepare and file quarterly submissions (4 times per year) plus the final declaration, fees increase to approximately £600 annually. This is due to the significantly increased administrative work.
Why This Makes Limited Companies More Attractive:
Limited companies are NOT subject to MTD for Income Tax. They continue operating under existing rules with annual filings only. At the £50,000+ profit level where MTD applies, the accounting fees for sole traders (£600/year with MTD) become similar to entry-level limited company accounting fees (£150/month = £1,800/year), but limited companies offer significantly better tax efficiency and more allowances.
The bottom line: If your turnover is approaching or exceeds £50,000, switching to a limited company before April 2026 means you'll avoid MTD quarterly filings entirely while gaining superior tax planning opportunities and similar accounting costs.
Understanding Sole Trader Status
Operating as a sole trader is the simplest way to run a business in the UK. You are the business. Everything is in your personal name, and you're personally responsible for everything the business does.
How It Works
As a sole trader, you register with HMRC for Self Assessment and operate under your own name (or a trading name). You keep records of income and expenses, submit a Self Assessment tax return once yearly, and pay Income Tax and National Insurance on all business profit. The business and you are legally the same entity. All profit belongs to you automatically, and you can withdraw money whenever you want.
Best For:
New businesses testing the market, side hustles alongside employment, simple service-based businesses with low overheads, annual profits under £30,000, anyone who values simplicity over tax efficiency.
How You're Taxed
Your taxable profit (income minus expenses) is added to any other income you have and taxed through Self Assessment:
• Personal Allowance: £12,570 tax-free
• Basic rate (20%): £12,571 - £50,270
• Higher rate (40%): £50,271 - £125,140
• Additional rate (45%): Over £125,140
Plus National Insurance:
• Class 2 NI: £3.45/week if profit over £12,570
• Class 4 NI: 6% on profits £12,570-£50,270, then 2% over £50,270
Important: Payment on Account means you pay estimated tax twice yearly (January and July) based on previous year's bill.
Advantages & Disadvantages
✓ Advantages
- Extremely simple to set up and run - can start trading immediately
- Minimal paperwork - just one tax return per year (under £50K turnover)
- Low accounting costs - £300 one-off for annual tax return
- Complete control - all decisions are yours alone
- Keep all profits after tax - no restrictions on withdrawing money
- Financial privacy - your income stays private
- Easy to close down if business doesn't work out
- Can operate under your own name or trading name
✗ Disadvantages
- Unlimited personal liability - your house and savings are at risk
- Less tax-efficient at higher profit levels (£30K+)
- All profit taxed regardless of whether you withdraw it
- May appear less professional to corporate clients
- Harder to raise investment or get business loans
- Limited tax planning opportunities
- Can't claim employer pension contributions as business expense
- From April 2026: Quarterly MTD filings if turnover exceeds £50K
Understanding Limited Company Status
A limited company is a separate legal entity distinct from you personally. The company owns the business assets, enters contracts in its own name, and you become a director and shareholder. This separation creates legal protection and tax planning opportunities.
How It Works
You form a company with Companies House, becoming a director and shareholder. The company is a separate legal person that owns the business assets and employs you as a director. You must file annual accounts, submit Corporation Tax returns, run payroll for any salaries, and maintain proper company records. Profits belong to the company, not you personally. You extract money via salary and dividends, which must be properly documented.
Best For:
Established businesses with consistent profits over £30K, contractors and consultants with high day rates, businesses wanting liability protection, companies planning significant growth, those needing professional credibility for corporate clients, businesses approaching £50K turnover wanting to avoid MTD requirements.
How You're Taxed
Company level:
• Small Profits Rate: 19% Corporation Tax on profits up to £50,000
• Main Rate: 25% Corporation Tax on profits over £250,000
• Marginal relief between £50K-£250K
Personal level (extracting money):
• Salary: Subject to Income Tax and NI (employer + employee)
• Dividends: Tax-free up to £500, then 8.75% (basic), 33.75% (higher), 39.35% (additional)
• Optimal strategy: Small salary (£9,100-£12,570) + dividends for remainder
Key advantage: Two-stage taxation (company then personal) with dividends taxed at lower rates than Income Tax creates significant savings at higher profit levels.
Advantages & Disadvantages
✓ Advantages
- Limited liability protects your personal assets from business debts
- More tax-efficient at profits over £30K-£50K with salary/dividend mix
- Employer pension contributions fully tax-deductible
- Professional image attracts larger clients and contracts
- Better access to business funding and investment
- Flexible profit extraction - decide when to take dividends
- Multiple directors/shareholders can share ownership
- NOT subject to MTD quarterly filing requirements
- Can sell the business as a going concern
- Enhanced tax planning opportunities with accountant
✗ Disadvantages
- Higher accounting fees - typically £150-£250/month (£1,800-£3,000/year)
- More admin - annual accounts, Corporation Tax, director tax return, payroll
- Annual accounts become public on Companies House
- Must follow company law and proper procedures
- Cannot simply withdraw money - must pay via salary/dividends
- Requires separate business bank account
- More complex bookkeeping and record-keeping requirements
- Closing down is more involved than sole trader
- Costs more to incorporate initially (£12-£100)
Real Tax Comparison: How Much You Actually Pay
Numbers speak louder than theory. Here are three realistic profit scenarios showing exactly what you'd pay as a sole trader versus a limited company. These calculations demonstrate why the limited company structure becomes increasingly beneficial as your profit grows.
Scenario 1: Lower Profit
Sole Trader
Limited Company
At this level, sole trader is slightly better due to Corporation Tax. But limited liability and professional image may still justify incorporation.
Scenario 2: Medium Profit
Sole Trader
Limited Company
BUT: From April 2026, MTD quarterly filing requirements apply to sole traders. Accounting fees increase from £300 to £600 annually. Combined with liability protection, limited company becomes the better choice at this level.
Scenario 3: Higher Profit
Sole Trader
Limited Company
Clear winner. Limited company saves £3,651 annually. Even after higher accounting fees (£1,800-£3,000/year), you're still better off by £651-£1,851 PLUS you get liability protection and professional credibility.
📊 The Crossover Point: For most London businesses, limited company becomes financially beneficial once annual profit consistently exceeds £30,000-£50,000. With MTD quarterly filing requirements from April 2026 affecting sole traders earning £50K+ turnover, the crossover point has effectively lowered, making limited companies attractive even sooner.
LOYALS Accounting Services: Clear Pricing for Both Structures
Understanding the accounting costs for each structure helps you make the right financial decision. Here's exactly what you'll pay for professional chartered accountant services at LOYALS, regardless of which structure you choose.
Self Assessment Service
- Full preparation of Self Assessment tax return
- Electronic submission to HMRC
- Tax optimization and expense review
- HMRC correspondence handling
- Deadline management and reminders
- Payment on Account reduction claims
Perfect For:
New businesses, side hustles, service providers with simple expenses, annual turnover under £50,000, anyone wanting affordable professional tax return preparation.
Self Assessment + MTD Service
- Quarterly tax preparation and filing
- MTD-compliant digital record-keeping
- Final year-end declaration
- Proactive Payment on Account management
- Pension planning advice
- Year-round HMRC correspondence handling
⚠️ Why £600? Making Tax Digital requires quarterly submissions (4 times per year) plus final declaration. This significantly increases our administrative work compared to a single annual return.
Premium Accounting Package
- Annual accounts and Corporation Tax return
- Director's Self Assessment tax return
- Full payroll processing (salary + dividends)
- VAT returns (if registered)
- Companies House filings
- Professional invoice management
- Debt recovery support
- Unlimited support 7 days/week
Perfect For:
Established businesses, profits £30K-£50K+, contractors and consultants, businesses wanting liability protection, avoiding MTD quarterly filings.
💡 The Math at £50,000+ Profit Level
Sole Trader (MTD)
Accounting fees
Tax bill
Total annual cost
Quarterly MTD filings required
Limited Company
Accounting fees
Tax bill (optimized)
Total annual cost
Annual filings only
Plus you get limited liability protection, professional credibility, no quarterly MTD filings, better tax planning, and employer pension contributions!
This is why at the £50,000+ profit level, limited company becomes the obvious choice. Yes, accounting fees are higher (£1,800 vs £600), but you save so much more in tax (£3,500+) that you're still better off by £2,300+ annually. Add in liability protection and avoiding quarterly MTD filings, and the decision becomes clear.
🎯 LOYALS Makes the Switch Seamless
We handle 100% of the incorporation process and ensure smooth transition from sole trader to limited company. Hundreds of London businesses have switched to limited company through LOYALS specifically because we make it completely hassle-free. We set up your company, configure optimal salary/dividend strategy, handle all HMRC registrations, and provide ongoing support. Call 07450 258975 or book a consultation to discuss your specific situation.
When Should You Stay as a Sole Trader?
Despite the tax advantages of limited companies at higher profits, sole trader status remains the right choice for many situations. Here's when keeping things simple makes the most sense.
Starting Out
Testing your business idea
- Just launching your business
- Not sure if it will succeed
- Want to test the market first
- Don't want setup complexity
- Easy to stop if it doesn't work
Lower Income
Earning under £30K profit
- Annual profit under £30,000
- Tax savings don't justify fees
- Keep accounting costs low
- Minimal admin burden
- Simple one tax return yearly
Side Hustle
Part-time alongside employment
- Working full-time elsewhere
- Side business for extra income
- Don't want double admin
- Irregular income patterns
- May stop at any time
Simple Services
Low overheads, minimal risk
- Service-based business
- Low liability risk
- No expensive equipment
- No employees to manage
- Just selling your time
Value Privacy
Keep finances confidential
- Don't want public accounts
- Prefer financial privacy
- Clients don't need to see turnover
- Personal brand business
- No corporate clients requiring Ltd
Hate Admin
Want absolute minimum paperwork
- Strongly prefer simplicity
- Don't want multiple filings
- Comfortable with one tax return
- No time for extra compliance
- Would rather pay more tax than do admin
Stay Sole Trader If...
Your annual profit is consistently under £30,000 AND you value simplicity over tax efficiency AND you don't need limited liability protection AND your industry doesn't require limited company status AND (from 2026) your turnover stays under £50,000 to avoid MTD quarterly filings.
When Should You Form a Limited Company?
Limited company status becomes increasingly attractive as your business grows and becomes more established. Here are the clear signals that incorporation makes financial and professional sense.
Higher Profits
Earning £30K-£50K+ annually
- Profit consistently over £30K
- Tax savings justify accounting fees
- From 2026: avoiding MTD requirements
- Salary/dividend mix saves thousands
- Can afford proper accountant
Liability Protection
Need to protect personal assets
- High-value contracts
- Potential client disputes
- Expensive equipment or inventory
- Employees to manage
- Protect family home and savings
Professional Image
Working with corporate clients
- Corporate clients prefer Ltd companies
- Winning larger contracts
- Tendering for public sector work
- Building supplier relationships
- Perceived as more established
Growth Plans
Scaling beyond current size
- Planning to hire employees
- Seeking business investment
- Want to bring in partners
- Building something to sell
- Expanding into new markets
Tax Planning
Want advanced tax strategies
- Maximize pension contributions
- Control when you take income
- Involve family members
- Defer tax to future years
- Optimize salary/dividend split
Established Business
Proven sustainable model
- Consistent income for 2+ years
- Building business equity
- Long-term client relationships
- Stable business model
- Ready for next growth phase
Go Limited Company If...
Your annual profit exceeds £30,000-£50,000 OR you need liability protection OR you work with corporate clients requiring Ltd status OR you're planning significant growth OR you want advanced tax planning opportunities OR (from 2026) your turnover exceeds £50,000 and you want to avoid MTD quarterly filing requirements.
How to Switch from Sole Trader to Limited Company
Making the transition requires some planning, but the process is straightforward when you understand the key steps and timing considerations.
The Switching Process
Switching from sole trader to limited company involves setting up a new company and transferring your business operations to it. You'll form a limited company with Companies House, typically taking your existing trading name if available. Your new company then needs a business bank account and appropriate insurance. You'll notify HMRC that you've ceased self-employment and register your new company for Corporation Tax. Any business assets, contracts, and supplier relationships transfer to the company. Your accountant handles closing your Self Assessment records as a sole trader and setting up the new company accounts and payroll systems.
Timing Your Switch
The best time to switch is at your financial year-end to keep accounting clean and simple. Many businesses switch on 5 April (end of UK tax year) or at their accounting reference date. Switching mid-year creates complications with apportioning income and expenses between structures, increasing accounting complexity and costs. If you're approaching £50,000 turnover, consider switching before April 2026 when Making Tax Digital quarterly filing requirements begin for sole traders at this level. Planning your switch 2-3 months in advance gives time for proper setup without rushing.
What Actually Transfers
Your business name transfers to the company if available at Companies House. Ongoing client contracts can continue under your new company. Equipment and assets transfer at market value, which may have tax implications. Your existing bank account stays personal, and you'll need a new business account. Suppliers and creditors need notification of the change. Importantly, your trading history, experience, and client relationships all continue seamlessly. What doesn't transfer automatically are registrations with regulatory bodies, which need updating, along with any licenses, permits, or professional accreditations.
Costs Involved
Companies House incorporation costs £12-£50 for online formation or £71 for same-day paper filing. Formation agents charge £30-£100 including extra services like registered office address. Professional advice from an accountant for the switch typically costs £200-£500. Setting up payroll and accounting software adds £20-£50 monthly. Business bank accounts for limited companies may have monthly fees of £5-£20. Ongoing accounting fees then become £150-£250 per month depending on complexity. While these costs are higher than sole trader, the tax savings at higher profit levels more than compensate.
💡 LOYALS Can Handle Everything
We manage 100% of the incorporation process for our clients. We form your company, set up your accounts and payroll, register with HMRC, advise on optimal salary/dividend split, and ensure smooth transition from sole trader to limited company. Many London businesses switch to LOYALS specifically because we make this complex transition completely seamless. Call us on 07450 258975 or book a consultation to discuss your specific situation.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Whether you're choosing your initial structure or considering a switch, avoid these costly mistakes that trip up many London business owners.
Incorporating Too Early
Before you're ready
- Starting with a limited company costs more upfront
- Higher ongoing accounting fees when profit is low
- Extra admin burden while testing business idea
- Stay sole trader until profit consistently hits £30K
- Exception: if clients require Ltd status immediately
Incorporating Too Late
Missing years of tax savings
- Many wait until £60K-£80K profit - too late!
- Missing £3,000-£5,000 annual tax savings
- From 2026: hitting MTD threshold unnecessarily
- Switch once profit consistently exceeds £30-50K
- Professional advice pays for itself many times over
Poor Timing
Switching mid-tax-year
- Mid-year switches create complex apportionments
- Higher accounting fees for split-year returns
- Potential gaps in accounting periods
- Always switch at financial year-end
- April or your accounting reference date is ideal
DIY Accounting
Trying to save money
- Limited companies have complex compliance requirements
- One mistake costs more than accountant fees
- Missing tax planning opportunities
- Late filing penalties up to £1,500+
- Professional help pays for itself in savings
Wrong for IR35
Contractors and structure
- Inside IR35? Limited company loses tax advantages
- Must take salary, can't optimize dividends
- Still pay accounting fees without tax benefits
- Sole trader often better for inside-IR35 work
- Get specialist contractor advice before deciding
Personal/Business Mixing
Not keeping them separate
- Limited companies require strict separation
- Can't just withdraw cash from company account
- Personal expenses through company = illegal loan
- Must pay via proper salary and dividends only
- Mixing creates serious tax and legal problems
How LOYALS Helps London Businesses Choose the Right Structure
We've helped over 500 London businesses across all boroughs make this crucial decision. Whether you're just starting out or ready to switch, we provide expert guidance tailored to your specific situation.
Free Structure Review
Book a free 30-minute consultation where we review your current situation, analyze your profit projections, calculate exactly how much you'd save with each structure, factor in the April 2026 MTD requirements, explain liability considerations for your industry, and provide clear recommendations based on your circumstances. We give you real numbers showing which structure saves you the most money right now and over the next 3-5 years. No obligation, no pressure, just honest advice from chartered accountants who've seen every scenario.
Complete Switching Service
If you decide to switch from sole trader to limited company, we handle absolutely everything. We incorporate your company with Companies House, set up your business bank account, register with HMRC for Corporation Tax and PAYE, close down your Self Assessment records properly, transfer existing contracts and suppliers, set up optimal salary and dividend strategy, implement proper bookkeeping systems, and ensure zero tax penalties or compliance gaps. Most switches complete within 7-10 days with minimal disruption to your business.
Ongoing Accounting for Either Structure
Whether you stay sole trader or go limited, we provide exceptional accounting support. For sole traders under £50K turnover, our service costs £300 one-off for your annual Self Assessment including full preparation, submission, tax optimization, and HMRC correspondence handling. For sole traders over £50K turnover affected by MTD from April 2026, we charge £600 per year covering quarterly digital submissions and year-end declaration. For limited companies, our Premium Accounting package starts at £150/month including all compliance, Corporation Tax, director tax returns, payroll, VAT returns, and unlimited support seven days per week.
Growth Support Beyond Numbers
Unlike traditional accountants who just file returns, LOYALS actively helps you grow. Our Business Mentor package (£250/month) includes everything in Premium Accounting plus monthly strategic sessions helping you scale your business. Our Business Growth Programme (£2000/month) provides a complete business team including accounting, legal advice, marketing specialists, and sales coaching. We've helped London businesses grow from £50K to £1M+ turnover across Westminster, Camden, Islington, Hackney, Tower Hamlets, Southwark, and all London boroughs. Extended hours Mon-Fri 9am-6pm and Sat-Sun 10am-5pm mean we're available when you need us.
🏆 Why Choose LOYALS?
We're chartered accountants who specialize in helping London businesses make smart structure decisions. We've completed hundreds of successful incorporations, avoided countless MTD compliance headaches, and saved our clients millions in unnecessary tax. We don't just crunch numbers – we provide strategic advice that actually grows your business. Our clients have recovered over £500,000 in unpaid invoices through our debt recovery service, and our business networking connects you with 500+ other London businesses for opportunities and collaborations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Ready to Choose the Right Structure for Your London Business?
Stop guessing. Get expert advice from chartered accountants who've helped 500+ London businesses make this crucial decision.
✅ Real tax calculations for your situation
✅ MTD impact analysis before April 2026
✅ Complete incorporation service if needed
✅ Ongoing support for either structure
Or call 07450 258975
Mon-Fri 9am-6pm · Sat-Sun 10am-5pm