The short answer: who pays the unpaid PAYE
The company pays, and because you are buying the company, that comes to mean you. A share purchase is the purchase of the legal entity itself, with everything inside it, so the unpaid PAYE does not get left on the seller's side of the table the way it would in a sale of just the business and its assets. The debt sits in the company before completion and it sits in the same company the morning after, now under your ownership.
That is not a reason to walk away from the deal. It is a reason to treat the historic PAYE as part of the price. Once you know the real number, including what HMRC will add in penalties and interest, you can hold money back, reduce the price, or get the seller to agree in writing to meet it. What you cannot do is assume it melts away at completion, because it does not.
Why the debt stays with the company
A limited company is a separate legal person in its own right. Under section 16 of the Companies Act 2006 a company on incorporation becomes a body corporate that is distinct from its shareholders, so its contracts, its tax and its debts belong to the company and not to whoever happens to own the shares. The company is the employer for PAYE, it runs the payroll, and the PAYE and National Insurance it deducts and owes are its liabilities.
Change the shareholders and none of that moves. The owners above the company have changed, but the company underneath is the same legal person it always was, still carrying the same payroll history and the same unpaid tax. That is the whole point of a share deal for an operating children's home: the home, its staff, its Ofsted registration and its contracts stay inside one unbroken company, which is tidy for continuity but means the bad comes across with the good.
An asset purchase works the other way. There you buy the home, the equipment and the goodwill out of the seller's company, and the seller's company keeps its own tax history, so its unpaid PAYE normally stays behind with it. The trade-off is that nothing is automatic: staff move across under transfer-of-undertaking rules, contracts have to be renovated, and, for a regulated setting, your own entity has to be registered before it can operate. The buyer's own company records then start from the handover, which is why keeping proper company and accounting records from day one matters whichever route you take.
How big the bill gets with penalties and interest
The figure in the accounts is rarely the figure you inherit. HMRC adds a late payment penalty that climbs with how many times the company paid its monthly PAYE late in a tax year. As set out in HMRC's guidance on what happens if you do not pay PAYE and National Insurance on time, the first late month in a year is not counted, then one to three defaults carry a 1 percent penalty, four to six carry 2 percent, seven to nine carry 3 percent, and ten or more carry 4 percent, each worked out on the amount paid late.
On top of that, any amount still unpaid after six months picks up a further 5 percent, and another 5 percent if it is still outstanding after twelve months. Daily interest runs the whole time, from the date the tax was due until the day it is paid. So a target that drifted into paying PAYE late across a year, and then left the balance sitting, can turn a few thousand pounds of underpaid tax into a materially larger liability by the time it shows up in your review. That tail is exactly what you want quantified before you agree a price, not discovered after.
How to protect yourself in the deal
Protection comes from the sale agreement, not from goodwill. A seller telling you the payroll is all up to date is not something you can bank, and it is not something HMRC will honour. What stands up is written: warranties that the stated position is true, a tax covenant that puts the cost of pre-completion tax back on the seller, and money held where you can reach it if the debt turns out to be real. The table below is how we line up each payroll risk against the protection that actually answers it.
Separating the company's own liabilities from the seller's promises, and the contract term that covers each one:
| What the review finds | Who it lands on in a share deal | Protection to ask for |
|---|---|---|
| Unpaid employer PAYE and NIC for past months | The company, so you after completion | Tax covenant plus a retention held from the price |
| Penalties and interest on late PAYE | The company | Warranty that filings and payments are up to date |
| Staff paid as self-employed who should be on payroll | The company | Specific indemnity for the identified exposure |
| Pension auto-enrolment arrears | The company | Warranty on pension compliance and contributions |
| Seller's verbal assurance that it is all clean | Nobody, unless it is written down | Replace the promise with a warranty and a covenant |
The order the work happens in matters as much as the terms. You find the debt in due diligence, you quantify it with HMRC rather than guessing, you write the protection into the agreement, you complete, and only then do you correct the position and, if the covenant provides for it, recover the cost from the seller. Skip the quantifying step and the covenant is written around a number nobody has checked.
Historic PAYE acquisition checklist
- Pull the target's employer PAYE account balance for every open tax year, not just the current one.
- Reconcile the Full Payment Submissions and Employer Payment Summaries filed against what was actually paid.
- Check the P30 payment records and any time-to-pay arrangement already running with HMRC.
- List workers paid as self-employed or through intermediaries and test whether they should be on the payroll.
- Confirm the pension auto-enrolment position, including backdated contributions and any regulator correspondence.
- Get the penalty and interest tail quantified, not just the headline tax, so the number is complete.
- Set a retention and a tax covenant in the agreement that match the exposure the review found.
- Agree who files the corrections after completion and who funds the final settled figure.
What it means for a children's home specifically
There is a reason owners of regulated homes so often buy the shares rather than the assets, and it is continuity. The Ofsted registration sits with the provider, and Ofsted's registration policy is clear that the provider is the legal entity running the home, with a company's details matched to what Companies House holds. Buy the shares and that legal entity does not change, so the registration carries on without a break and the children in placement are not disturbed. Buy the business and assets instead and your own entity has to be registered before it can lawfully operate the home, which takes time and planning.
That continuity is a real advantage, but it is also why the unpaid PAYE comes with the keys. You are keeping the company precisely because everything stays attached to it, and the tax history is part of everything. You still have to tell Ofsted about the changes a sale brings, such as new directors or a new responsible individual, and keep the company's registered details current, while separately making sure the payroll tax you have inherited is corrected and paid. The guidance on how groups of children's homes work is a useful read when a deal adds a home into an existing group rather than standing alone.
A two-home group buys a third
Picture a children's care group with two settings buying the company behind a third home. The review finds the target paid its PAYE late through most of the prior year and left part of the balance outstanding, and that two waking-night staff had been paid as self-employed. The underpaid tax looks like a modest figure at first glance, but once the late payment penalties and the interest tail are added, and the two misclassified workers are brought into PAYE, the real exposure is several times larger.
Because it is a share deal, all of that sits in the company the group is buying. The fix is not to abandon the purchase, which keeps the Ofsted registration and the placements intact, but to quantify the full figure with HMRC, hold a retention from the price to cover it, and write a tax covenant so the seller funds their own period. The group completes, corrects the PAYE, and recovers the settled cost under the covenant. Figures here are illustrative, not a specific client.
How the three common ways of handling the payroll side of a children's home acquisition compare:
| On the acquisition | DIY / solicitor only | Generic accountant | LOYALS specialist |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pulls the target's employer PAYE account for every open period | โ Not their job | โ If asked | โ Standard in the review |
| Reconciles FPS and EPS filings to what was actually paid | โ | โ | โ Line by line |
| Separates the company's own PAYE from the seller's promises | โ Warranty wording only | โ | โ Risk matched to the covenant |
| Tests staff paid as self-employed for PAYE exposure | โ | โ | โ Care roles checked |
| Runs the home's payroll correctly from completion | โ | โ Extra engagement | โ One care finance engagement |
A solicitor drafts the protections, but someone has to find and size the payroll risk they are protecting against, and then run the payroll afterwards.
What to do before you complete the purchase
If a purchase review has found unpaid PAYE, the practical steps are the same whether the home stands alone or joins a group.
- Get the real number. Quantify the tax, the penalties and the interest with HMRC, not from the seller's summary, so the figure in the deal is the figure that exists.
- Price the risk. Decide whether it comes off the price, sits in a retention, or both, once you know the full exposure.
- Protect it in writing. A tax covenant and specific indemnities for what the review found, so the seller funds their own period rather than you.
- Keep the registration clean. Tell Ofsted about the director and responsible-individual changes and keep the Companies House record in step, so the regulated side stays in order.
- Correct it after completion. File the corrections, settle with HMRC, and claim back under the covenant, all as one piece of work rather than three loose ends.
Handled in that order, unpaid PAYE is a priced and funded line in the deal rather than a nasty surprise that lands on the new owner. LOYALS is a King's Cross firm of accountants and business consultants that runs payroll, acquisition reviews and ongoing finance for children's home and care groups across London, and we would rather find the number with you before completion than reconstruct it after. The verification is an hour or two of work that routinely saves a buyer many times its cost.