The short answer: repay only if two things are true
Repay a challenged dividend only when both of these are true: the dividend was unlawful, and the person who received it knew or had reasonable grounds to believe it was unlawful when they took it. If either one fails, there is no personal liability to hand the money back. That is the test, and most of the panic around a challenged dividend comes from skipping it and assuming the worst.
A dividend is unlawful if the company did not have the profits to pay it. Section 830 of the Companies Act 2006 says a company may only distribute out of profits available for the purpose, and defines those as its accumulated realised profits less its accumulated realised losses. If the reserves were there, the dividend was lawful and the challenge goes nowhere, whatever the paperwork looked like. If they were not, you move to the second question of who, if anyone, has to repay. The monthly numbers that answer the first question are exactly what a proper management accounts service keeps current, which is why the challenge is so often really a records problem.
This guide is written by LOYALS, a King's Cross firm of accountants and business consultants that runs company accounts, corporation tax and tax planning for owner managed businesses across London, so the framing is the decision a director actually faces when the letter or the awkward board conversation lands, not a lecture on company law.
What makes a dividend unlawful in the first place
A dividend is lawful when two conditions are met: the company had enough distributable profit to cover it, and it was properly declared. The first is the one that trips people up, because distributable profit is not the same as cash in the bank or the profit on this month's management figures.
Distributable reserves are cumulative. They are every realised profit the company has ever made, less every realised loss, less everything already paid out as dividends or capitalised. A company can be busy and cash-rich this year and still have no distributable reserves because earlier losses sit against the profits. Section 836 then sets the evidence test: whether a distribution is lawful is judged by reference to the "relevant accounts", which are normally the last filed annual accounts. Where the last annual accounts do not show enough, interim accounts prepared to a date before the dividend can justify it instead, and in a company's first accounting period initial accounts can be used. You judge the dividend against what those accounts show, not against a hunch about how trading is going.
So a dividend most often gets challenged for one of three reasons: there were accumulated losses that wiped out the apparent profit, the dividend was paid part way through a year on the strength of profits that had not actually been earned yet, or there simply are no accounts that support it. Our tax planning and advisory team sees the middle one most, where an owner drew regular monthly amounts as dividends across a year that then closed at a smaller profit than the drawings assumed.
Read the chart as the whole case in one picture. The top bar is what the company could lawfully distribute, built from profit brought forward plus the realised profit earned in the period. The next bar is what was actually declared, and the gap between them is the unlawful excess. A challenge that looks frightening in a letter usually comes down to exactly this: how big were the reserves, and how much bigger was the dividend.
Reconstructing the reserves and the approval
A challenge asks two evidence questions, and you answer them with two different sets of records. The first is the reserves: can you show, from relevant accounts, that distributable profits covered the dividend on the day it was paid. The second is the authority: was the dividend properly declared, with the right people approving it and a record that it happened.
Authority matters because the two kinds of dividend are approved differently and crystallise at different moments. A final dividend is recommended by the directors and declared by the members by ordinary resolution, and once declared it becomes a debt the company owes. An interim dividend is decided by the directors alone and is not a debt until it is actually paid, which gives directors room to reverse an unpaid interim dividend that turns out not to be covered. A dividend voucher and a board or shareholder minute showing the date, the amount and the reserves relied on are what turn "we took some money" into "we declared a dividend". Where those are missing, the dividend is not necessarily unlawful, but it is undefended, and a challenger will press on the gap.
The evidence a challenged dividend needs, split by what it proves:
| What the challenge questions | The record that answers it | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Were there profits to pay it? | Relevant accounts showing distributable reserves at or before the dividend date | Last filed annual accounts, or interim accounts prepared to a date before the dividend |
| Was it actually declared? | Board minute for an interim dividend, or members' ordinary resolution for a final dividend | The company's statutory books and board papers |
| When and how much? | Dividend voucher for each shareholder, dated, with the amount per share | Issued at the time of payment, kept with the company records |
| Did the recipient know the position? | What accounts and figures the shareholder had sight of when paid | Management information, emails, the shareholder's role in the company |
| Has it been put right? | Corrected accounts, reversing entries, or a repayment record | Prepared once the lawful position is reconstructed |
The practical order is always reserves first. Rebuild the distributable reserves to the dividend date, bringing in any interim profit that was genuinely earned, before you worry about the minutes. More than half the challenges we see dissolve at this step, because the profit was there and the only real failing was that nobody wrote the paperwork up at the time. The paperwork can be prepared properly now; what cannot be invented is profit that never existed.
Does the shareholder actually have to repay it
Say the reserves genuinely were not there, so part of the dividend was unlawful. The next question is whether anyone has to give it back, and the answer is not automatically yes. Section 847 of the Companies Act 2006 makes a member liable to repay an unlawful distribution, or to pay the company its value if it was not in cash, but only where that member knew, or had reasonable grounds for believing, at the time of the distribution, that it was made unlawfully. A shareholder who met that test holds the money on trust for the company and has to return it. A shareholder who did not is outside section 847 and keeps the dividend.
For an owner managed company this usually points one way. The director shareholders had the accounts, ran the company and decided the dividend, so they will struggle to argue they had no reasonable grounds to know the reserves were short. That is why, in a close company, an unlawful dividend taken by the owners is almost always repayable by them. The innocent-recipient route tends to protect a different person: an outside or minority shareholder who was simply paid their share and had no window onto the reserves. Section 847 also preserves any separate duty to repay that exists outside it, so a director who approved an unlawful dividend can face a claim as a director as well as as a shareholder.
What it means for your tax if it was unlawful
Whether a dividend is unlawful is a company law question, not a tax one, and HMRC says as much in its Company Taxation Manual at CTM15205 (updated 24 August 2026). The tax treatment then follows the facts, and it splits along the same knowing or innocent line as the repayment question.
A shareholder who knew or had reasonable grounds to know holds the dividend as a constructive trustee, and because they must repay it, the dividend is treated as void for income tax. It never formed part of their income, so there is no dividend tax on it, but the money has to go back. The sting is in close companies. HMRC treats the unlawful dividend to the owner as a loan to a participator, which brings the section 455 charge into play: corporation tax at 33.75 percent of the outstanding amount for loans made on or after 6 April 2022, as at November 2026. That charge is temporary and the company reclaims it once the amount is repaid, written off or released, with the repayment relief available from nine months and one day after the end of the accounting period in which the balance is cleared. Clear it within nine months and one day of the year end and the charge does not bite at all.
A shareholder with no knowledge and no reasonable grounds for belief is in a different position. They are not a constructive trustee, they do not have to repay, and the sum is taxed as an ordinary distribution. If they choose to repay anyway, HMRC treats that as a voluntary transfer of their own income, so it does not rewrite the tax they already owe. That asymmetry is why naming the right recipient early matters: the same unlawful dividend is a repayable section 455 loan for one shareholder and a taxable distribution that stays put for another.
Where a challenged dividend can end up once the facts are clear:
| Finding | What happens to the money | Tax effect |
|---|---|---|
| Lawful after reconstruction | Nothing repaid, records tidied | Taxed as the dividend it always was |
| Unlawful, recipient knew (close company owner) | Repaid, or sits as an overdrawn loan until cleared | Void for income tax; section 455 charge at 33.75 percent until repaid |
| Unlawful, recipient innocent | Kept by the shareholder | Taxed as a distribution; voluntary repayment does not change it |
| Reclassified as salary or bonus | Run through payroll instead | PAYE and National Insurance, often a worse outcome, so check before choosing it |
The challenged dividend review checklist
Here is the review we run, in order, when a dividend is challenged. Work through it before any money moves, because the earlier steps often remove the need for the later ones.
Challenged dividend review checklist
- Fix the date and the amount. Pin down exactly when the dividend was paid and how much, per shareholder, from the bank and the vouchers.
- Rebuild distributable reserves to that date. Take accumulated realised profits less accumulated realised losses, less earlier dividends, up to the dividend date, bringing in genuine interim profit.
- Identify the relevant accounts. Decide whether the last annual accounts support it, or whether interim accounts to a date before the dividend are needed under section 836.
- Check the authority. Find the board minute for an interim dividend or the members' resolution for a final one, and the dividend vouchers.
- Name each recipient and what they knew. Separate owner directors, who are usually treated as knowing, from outside shareholders who may be innocent recipients.
- Size the unlawful part, if any. Only the amount above the reserves is unlawful, not necessarily the whole dividend.
- Choose the correction. Prepare the missing accounts and minutes where the dividend was covered, or a repayment or loan-account treatment where it was not.
- Align company and director records. Make the accounts, the statutory books and each shareholder's personal tax position tell the same story.
A worked example you can follow
- A trading company has 60,000 pounds of retained profit brought forward and earns 25,000 pounds of realised profit in the year, so distributable reserves reach 85,000 pounds.
- The owner drew 120,000 pounds across the year as monthly dividends.
- The dividend is lawful up to 85,000 pounds. The remaining 35,000 pounds was never covered and is unlawful.
- Because the owner is a director with the figures, the 35,000 pounds is repayable, and in a close company it sits as a loan to the participator carrying the section 455 charge until it is cleared.
- The fix is to repay or formally treat the 35,000 pounds, correct the accounts, and set next year's drawings against profit actually earned.
Illustration, not client data. Your reserves and the covered amount will differ.
What to do now before you repay anything
The instinct when a dividend is challenged is to repay quickly and make the problem disappear. That instinct is usually wrong, and it can cost you. If the dividend was in fact covered, repaying it hands the company money it was never owed and muddles everyone's tax; if it was unlawful, repaying blindly without treating it correctly can leave a section 455 charge or a personal tax position that should have been handled differently.
What we would actually do is reconstruct the relevant accounts to the dividend date first, every time, because in most owner managed challenges the dividend proves lawful once interim profits are brought in and the only real job is writing up the minutes and vouchers that were missed. Where the reserves genuinely were short, we size the unlawful part, treat it as the loan it has become, and clear it inside the nine month window where we can to keep the section 455 charge off. That approach changes in one situation worth naming: where the recipient is an outside shareholder with no sight of the accounts, the innocent-recipient route usually applies, the money stays with them, and the company's job is to correct its own records rather than chase a repayment it cannot force.
HMRC's own director information hub (updated 11 September 2026) puts it plainly: pay dividends only from available profits, declare and record them before payment, and take professional advice to make sure a payment is lawful. A challenge is that advice arriving late. This guide is written by LOYALS, a King's Cross firm of accountants and business consultants that reconstructs distributable reserves, defends or corrects challenged dividends and aligns company and director records for owner managed businesses across London, and would rather tell you the dividend was lawful than watch you repay money you did not owe.