Can a small UK payroll really cap our R&D refund?
Yes, and it catches founders out every year. The payable R&D tax credit you can take as cash is limited to ยฃ20,000 plus 300 percent of the PAYE and National Insurance your company actually pays over for the period. A lean UK team with a lot of bought-in development can easily run a claim that is worth more than that ceiling, and when it does, the part above the cap does not land in your account. You have done real, qualifying R&D, the numbers are right, and you still cannot collect the full amount in cash this year.
The logic behind the cap is deliberate. It was brought in to stop companies with almost no UK presence claiming large cash credits, so it is built to reward employment and development carried out here. That means it bears down hardest on exactly the setup a lot of early software businesses run: two or three people on the UK books, and the heavy lifting done by an offshore agency or a connected development company. If that is you, the cap is not a rare edge case, it is the first thing to check. For a wider view of how a software claim fits together, our guide to R&D tax credits for UK SaaS startups sets out the scheme before this cap is applied, and the tech and SaaS accountants page covers the rest of the finance function around it.
LOYALS is a King's Cross firm of accountants and business consultants that prepares R&D claims for software companies across London, and the cap is one of the first figures we model, because telling a founder after filing that a third of the expected cash is stuck is a conversation nobody wants.
How is the PAYE and NIC cap actually worked out?
The cap is a single sum. Take the relevant PAYE and National Insurance your company is liable to pay for the accounting period, multiply it by 300 percent, and add a flat ยฃ20,000. The answer is the most payable credit you can receive for that period. HMRC sets this out in its R&D PAYE cap guidance, which also confirms that where the accounting period is shorter than twelve months, the ยฃ20,000 is scaled down in proportion.
Two details change the number in your favour. First, the PAYE and NIC that counts is not only the amount for staff whose time is in the claim; it is the company's relevant liability for the period, and in group situations the PAYE and NIC of connected companies that is attributable to the R&D can be brought in. Second, the base is your genuine payroll cost, so the salaries, employer National Insurance and employer pension contributions that count as qualifying staff costs are also the figures that lift the ceiling. Our tax planning and advisory work often starts here, because a founder on a token salary plus dividends is quietly holding their own cap down.
The chart below shows the shape of the problem on an illustrative claim.
Put real figures against it and the cap stops being abstract. The table below walks through the same illustrative claim, from the payroll base up to the capped refund.
| Step in the calculation | Illustrative figure |
|---|---|
| Relevant PAYE and NIC for the period | ยฃ20,000 |
| Multiply by 300 percent | ยฃ60,000 |
| Add the flat amount | ยฃ20,000 |
| Your PAYE and NIC cap | ยฃ80,000 |
| Payable credit the claim works out at | ยฃ110,000 |
| Refund the cap allows this year | ยฃ80,000 |
| Excess held back (carried forward or lost) | ยฃ30,000 |
When does the cap not apply? The two conditions
The cap is switched off for an accounting period when your company meets both of HMRC's conditions at once. Miss either and the cap is back in play, so this is a test you pass as a pair, not a menu.
Condition A is about who does the valuable work. It is met where your own employees are creating relevant intellectual property, preparing to create it, or managing it where the company already owns it, and that activity is carried out wholly or mainly by those employees. Directors count only when they are also employees. Condition B is a spending test: your qualifying expenditure on subcontractors and externally provided workers who are connected to your company must be no more than 15 percent of your total qualifying R&D spend for the period. The point of the pair is clear once you read them together. A company doing and owning its own innovation, without routing most of the spend through connected parties, is exactly the business the cap was never meant to restrict.
Does the cap even apply to you? Work through this first
- Are your own employees creating, preparing to create, or managing the relevant intellectual property, with that work done wholly or mainly in-house? (Condition A)
- Is your qualifying spend on connected subcontractors and externally provided workers 15 percent or less of your total qualifying R&D spend? (Condition B)
- If both are a clear yes, the cap does not restrict your claim for that period, whatever the payable credit works out at.
- If either is no, work out the cap: relevant PAYE and NIC, times three, plus ยฃ20,000, scaled down if the period is under twelve months.
- Then check whether connected companies' PAYE and NIC attributable to the R&D can be added to lift the cap.
What happens to the part of the refund above the cap?
This is where the scheme you are claiming under matters, and it is the detail that decides whether capped money is merely delayed or gone for good. Under the merged RDEC scheme, which runs for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 April 2024, the excess over the cap is not lost. It is carried forward and treated as an expenditure credit in your next accounting period, so you collect it later rather than never. Under Enhanced R&D Intensive Support, the loss-making route for R&D intensive companies, there is no carry forward at all: any payable credit above the cap is simply invalid. The rates behind each route, the 20 percent expenditure credit and the enhanced deduction for intensive companies, are set out in HMRC's guidance on the merged scheme and intensive support.
That split is not a technicality. The same ยฃ30,000 of capped credit in our illustration is a timing difference under RDEC and a permanent loss under the intensive route, so knowing which scheme your claim sits in before you file is worth real money.
The same ยฃ30,000, two very different outcomes
On the illustrative claim above, the cap holds ยฃ30,000 back. Under the merged RDEC scheme that ยฃ30,000 is carried forward and treated as an expenditure credit next period, so with enough PAYE and NIC headroom next year it is collected rather than lost.
Under Enhanced R&D Intensive Support the same ยฃ30,000 is invalid. There is no carry forward, so unless the cap is lifted or an exemption is met, that part of the credit is gone. Same figures, same work, a ยฃ30,000 difference driven only by the route.
Illustration, not client data. The figures are rounded and the outcome depends on your own scheme, payroll and claim value.
What to do before you count on the cash
If an R&D refund is part of your runway, treat the cap as a figure to confirm, not a surprise to discover after filing. The practical steps are short.
- Work the cap before you model the cash. Relevant PAYE and NIC, times three, plus ยฃ20,000. Compare it to the payable credit the claim produces, so you know whether any of it is at risk.
- Test the two conditions honestly. If your own people create and own the intellectual property and connected subcontractor and worker spend is at or below 15 percent, the cap drops away and the modelling is easy.
- Know your scheme. Carried forward under RDEC is a delay; invalid under the intensive route is a loss. Confirm which one your claim sits in before you decide how much to rely on.
- Look at payroll for next period. Where a founder or key developer is on a token salary, a commercially real UK salary raises the PAYE and NIC base and lifts the cap, with its own tax cost to weigh.
- Mind the filing mechanics. A first-time or lapsed claimant must send a claim notification within six months of the end of the period of account, and that requirement falls away only for claims made on or after 1 April 2027, so missing it loses the claim before the cap is even reached.
Done in that order, the cap is just one more number you have checked, not a hole in your forecast. LOYALS is a King's Cross firm of accountants and business consultants that prepares and defends R&D claims for software companies across London, and we would rather tell you the cap bites in September than have you find out in March when the cash does not arrive.